[0:00:00] Good evening. It is 6.06. I will call to order this meeting of the Burlington Police Commission. A few minutes late. Apologies. We are waiting on a quorum. So I will not do. I will do roll call. But we will skip to public forum. We will not vote on the agenda. I will start with roll call in person. Do we have Commissioner Karen Paul. Here. Commissioner Romeo van Herman. Here. OK. We do not have quorum. So we will move straight to public comment. Are there any members of the public who would like to be heard at this time. I do not see anyone in person at Conto. Is there anyone online? Okay, hearing no one, we will move to the next item that we can without quorum. We are anticipating someone joining momentarily. Chief, do you mind if we move right to your report? [0:00:49] Happy to do that. Thank you. But successfully share my screen. Yes. Excellent. Thank you. So, as in typical form, in the October 2026 data report from the Police Department includes incident arrest data that was compiled through the end of September of 2026. So the first illustration is just a top line incident responses across all divisions of the department sworn CSOs and CSLs 23,274 incidents thus far through the month of September. The next illustration is our staff levels. So we have typically had this broken down. [0:01:46] Only illustrating our sworn staff levels this this month is across the entire organization. So, in terms of administration, our professional staff, we have 5 of our 8 positions are filled community service officers, plus their manager. We have 5 of 9 total positions filled. So 44% vacancy rate in CSOs. Community support liaison plus their manager is a team of 7 1 vacancy at the level. We have our domestic violence advocate on staff in the dispatch center, our emergency communication specialists, plus their manager. That's allotted for 15. We have 2 vacancies in emergency communication specialists. identification unit is fully staffed with two records is fully staffed with four and sworn staff. So everyone here that can wear a uniform. [0:02:41] We have 54 positions of our allotted budget allotted 73 ish positions. So 26% bacon in terms of sworn officers. Moving along the next chart is by division, our community service officer incidents. The only thing I really like to highlight here is. That we illustrate the top types of incidents for which CSO, CSLs and sworn staff attend to month to month. And you'll see here with CSOs, we've got about 5 or 7 of their top incidents that really encapsulates all of the work that they are able to do here at the police department. because we do have an agreement with the Burlington Police Officers Association on what work a CSO can do. Moving along to our CSL team, [0:03:33] similar, they are attending to 5 or 7 incident types, the things that you would think about, the things that we synchronize through policy and protocol, where they're Conducting a number of welfare checks, encampment outreach, service coordination, agency assist and attending the mental health issues. Again, very effective team. They operate a hand in glove with our street outreach response and they are able to get a lot of the call volume off of the table of sworn officers. But there's limits as to what professional staff can do. And then, as we progress to the top incident types for sworn officers, you'll see, we have the better part of 20 incident types here shown. And that's because this is the work that we need a sworn police officer to attend to and going back to kind of our staffing situation. [0:04:27] This is where we have 1 of our greatest areas of vacancy. So, again, really nothing to call out here in terms of what was going on in September, but just to remind folks that. that there is ample work to do for our sworn staff, even though we've gone through the exercise of seeing exactly what professional staff can do in terms of incident response. Moving along to our concerted efforts to have foot in directed patrols of our hotspot areas, really what this amounts to is our efforts in the downtown district. You'll see 2026, these efforts have kind of fallen off a little bit. It's because of our available staff, but again, what I like to highlight is that we're still well above where the organization was in 2024 keeping pace or a little bit greater than efforts in 2023, but just not where we were in 2025. [0:05:23] When I look back at the headcount, we're down at least 10 sworn officers and several positions. People that do this work. When you look back at our historical levels of those 2 divisions in 23 and 24. Violent crime through September again, there's a seasonality to this when you look across the 3 years that are the 4 years here that are illustrated. There was definitely a high point here in 2024 not quite what the city experience in 2022, which is not illustrated here. But we are proud of the efforts that we have made in reducing violent crime, particularly in the downtown district. And again, this is filtered by those incident types that are on the right of the chart homicide, attempted homicide, reckless endangerment, which is a category that really accounts for gunfire that doesn't strike a person robbery and then misdemeanor and felony level assaults. [0:06:21] Moving along here to the metrics in City Hall Park. This graph shows incidents that are called in by members of the public that are occurring in City Hall Park. So extracted from this data set are proactive incidents, such as foot directed patrol and other officer initiated complaints. You'll see that the activity level as reported by the public is not as high as it was in 2025, more in line with what was seen in 23 and well above what was seen in 2024. That's not to say that the conditions in the park have been fantastic, but this is what the public is actually reporting to the police department that we're responding to. Because we know about our enforcement activities when they are robust in the park that we displace a lot of this behavior. We do track. A vicinity of city hall park, which is essentially about a 1 block radius around the park much. [0:07:21] Or I should say consistent with the previous chart, the incident levels here being reported by members of the public, not as high as 25 online with 23. Well, above what's going on in 24. Just to give you kind of a snapshot of what we've seen here in the recent weeks. Because of our efforts on the upper blocks of. College street adjacent to, or parallel to city hall park. We've seen a lot of the behavior move west down the hill. We're having some challenges on Pine Street in the area of College Street that we're contending with currently. Moving along to arrests, I do like to highlight this chart. There's been a narrative in the community that the police department is not enforcing the law. That's absolutely not true. Our arrest rate is as high as it was in 2026 despite our staffing challenges and above what was going on in 23. [0:08:20] And for the most part in 2024, what I do like to remind folks is that when we're making an arrest, that could be as simple as issuing a citation where the officer could go back in the service. If it involves an officer, say, by way of example, making an arrest on an arrest warrant during court hours, that officer goes off the street and has to sit at the courthouse with the defendant in custody until a judge is available. Oftentimes we'll lose an officer from the patrol deployment for 2 to 4 hours when this thing happened, when these incidents occur, which is quite often. And that's really debilitating when we only have 4 officers assigned to a day shift Monday through Friday. Moving along to drug arrests again, seasonality to this work. We. We're doing an enhanced number, an increased number of these arrests in 2025. 2026 has not been bad. I do like to call out that despite our staffing challenges, [0:09:19] we are exceeding those arrest numbers that were seen in earlier years being 23 and 24. There's still much more work that could be done down there, but kind of the counter that narrative that the police department is not enforcing the law. When we look at the data, we can actually illustrate clearly that we are doing our job and enforcing the law. Moving along the tickets and warnings. Again, you'll see the seasonality trends here. We were doing a lot more work with more people in 2025. 2026 started off great. I've talked with the Commission and the Public Safety Committee about why it dropped off in July when the City Circle program ended abruptly. Officers refrained from issuing a lot of these ordinance tickets simply because when there isn't any accountability, people aren't showing up for the restorative process. The City Attorney's Office is not filing these matters. [0:10:16] With the criminal legal system, the officers do not see the benefit in issuing these tickets oftentimes the population that we're dealing with when you think about open containers, public drug use. They know, in fact, that they don't need to attend to these tickets because there isn't any accountability. So we will be I have highlighted this for the public safety committee. I know that the mayor has been focused upon what this should actually look like in terms of using the city attorney's office, limited resources and potentially filing these, these matters as criminal when warranted. But that is why we saw a decline this summer in this enforcement. [0:10:55] The top monthly tickets are warnings issued seasonal trends. Once again, nothing really new to report here. The top 4 being disorderly conduct open container and then drug possession, which is actually drug usage. and alcohol possession or open container, both violations occurring in City Hall Park. Now we're going to talk about the, what I call the impact cohort. So there's a small number of people that drive a outsized number of incidents. So when Jeff Nicholson prepares this data, what he looks for is essentially an endpoint. The top consumer has about 90 incidents thus far this year, where we broke off this data set with someone that had 17 incidents with the police department, that number of people is 72 and they account for 20% of the incidents the police department has been responding to. What do we know about this population? [0:11:54] 66% of the group is unhoused. The other remainder report having an address. And when we get into how they present in our data set, this will be very easy to understand. So when we're talking about our impact cohort, 66% of whom are unhoused. They have accounted for 367 trespass incidents, couple hundred suspicious incidents, a chunk of our ordinance violations, disturbance, arrest on warrants 104 through September of this year, drug incidents, mental health issues and retail theft. What does that look like as a percentile of those overall incident categories? So, 27% of the total number of trespass incidents, the department has responded to 18% of our suspicious events. 20% of our ordinance violation and then I like to skip down to 22% of our arrest on warrant 26% of our drug complaints. [0:12:54] 20% of our mental health issues and 26% of our retail thefts, which is substantial in my mind. And then here's the graphic of how they present. So the top consumer, I said, just shy of 90 incidents. The number is actually 86 and then it tails off here to 17. What's the police department doing in terms of using all the resources available to us in order to try to help people improve their situation and hold them accountable. So, this graph actually shows of these top. This should be, this should be 72. Last month, it was a 64 so that just copied over in the graph that came over from Jeff. The blue bars indicate those that have been referred to the situation table. The red bars indicate those that are in the support court, which is run by state attorney Sarah George. [0:13:50] The purple bar, both situation table and support court and the green bar treatment court. What we are going to do this coming month, we have an intern working with us from Champlain College. We have the latest probation and parole incident. We're going to be able to put a new filter on this data set to see who is on the headcount for probation and parole and being supervised in that regard. [0:14:16] Moving along here, just illustrating officer workload, median sworn officer response by count by month. So here in July, we hit a high water mark of 90 incidents per officer as a response rate. When you look back over nearly the last decade, you can see kind of how outsized this has gotten, has become since 2023 when we've lost a large number of staff. Of course, there's a seasonality to this too, and it's dropping off now. We'll see, like it's been a, thus far, it's been a pretty cool fall. And as we get into winter, I anticipate that this will level out a little bit more. The next chart shows the number of sworn officers who have responded to a hundred or more calls per month. Again, last summer in 2025, we were seeing at least 22 officers. That's substantial because in 2025, we had about 22 or 24 officers assigned to the patrol division. [0:15:15] Here in 2026, it reached a high mark of 23 back in July. It's at a time where we had 20 officers assigned to uniform services. So this is actually encapsulating or catching the responses of officers from detectives and other divisions that are working overtime to help us shore up our patrol schedule. [0:15:40] And despite all of that, we still have been able to reduce our response time of less than an hour. So this is just a graph that shows from 23 to 2026, the percentage of calls with a response time of less than one hour. You'll see in 2024, the police department wasn't being quite as responsive, probably as the public expected, maybe even as the public is needed at the time. And since 2025, we've been on an upward trajectory despite having, you know, from 2025, we've had nine retirements and about five or six resignations leaving us again at that number of 54 police officers total on staff here at the Burlington police. And with that, I'm happy to take any questions. Thanks, chief. Other questions or comments from commissioners? Romeo? Thank you, chair. Quickly, just looking at chief, the incidents in the vicinity of City [0:16:40] Hall Park, though it looks like to a certain degree there are things that are going down, but it looks like from what you're saying is that issuing tickets is not deterring anything. And so just looking at the chart, I'm noticing where it says top monthly tickets warning issued. It's done not in part because, in sense they're down, but because of accountability, it's not happening. Is that correct? Yeah, that's a fair character division. I do believe that ticketing does have an effect with some folks, but I would say with some of the more challenging cases downtown, some of the more prolific people that are well aware how this system works, that it is not an effective tool unless there is ultimately some type of accountability measure for violating the city ordinance. Okay, and the deficiencies not necessarily lie with the police department per se. [0:17:39] That is what it looks like from what I'm looking at the chart. And also from what you mentioned is having an officer assigned to a defendant when they at the court, which creates a situation where there's one more or less officer present. Are there anything that beyond what is shown this presentation that either the administration or at the court or the city attorney's office, they're doing to mitigate that? And all staffing is really an issue. Is there anything else that can be done to elevate that? And I know from what I heard, there's somewhat of a surplus, hopefully expecting more people to be hired. But looking at the totality of the situation where when folks go to the academy and then they hear, they're asked if they want to come to Burlington, they're not necessarily eager to come here. Is that playing into this whole scenario situation where we have just a few number [0:18:39] of individuals that are addressing the issue and then there's one person pulled out? And then we have a little bit of funds that is still available to hire additional folks, but folks don't want to be here. Would that be accurate? So I think there's a couple of things afoot here. One is we've got a recruitment challenge. Our application numbers are very low this year. And we are receiving some support from outside the organization to help us think about new ways to advertise and market the job opportunities here in Burlington. I will say, you know, across the country that there's a deficit of police officers, there's a recruitment challenge in many, many cities. In terms of what's going on with the criminal legal system, the court only operates so fast that this does not concern the city attorney's office whatsoever. [0:19:35] When you bring a defendant to court for an unscheduled arraignment, which when you pick someone up off the street under arrest warrant, they weren't expecting us, we're not on the docket. So they have to find a judge, a prosecutor, oftentimes a defense attorney, to deal with that proceeding, and it's time consuming. And the criminal legal system is not overly efficient by its nature, and this is a complication that I like to highlight simply because when we have so few officers assigned to patrol, when you lose someone between two, four, five to six hours that can be, that can hamper operations. So are there probably some other strategies that we may want to think about? I'm anxious to talk with the new chief about his ideas around this, but there's oftentimes a sheriff in the court, they're not paid to be there, but could we maybe look at a way of contracting with a sheriff to take over these prisoners? Potentially we could do that, [0:20:33] but again, our fiscal resources are not endless, so we need to be careful with those. And then just to come back to the recruitment piece, I wanna be clear that we have a lot of funding to do recruitment. We have a lot of funding to employ police officers. We need qualified applicants, and that's been vexing for us. Thank you, Chief. Just looking at the final point that I wanna make, it's not so much of a question, looking at the monthly arrests match between 2025 and 2026. I do see that the police department is taking accountability in terms of arresting people who are doing whatever they're doing. And I just wanna thank you for showing us this data to help us understand what's happening. And it's unfortunate that accountability is not happening, but I'm hoping that as time goes on, looking at July this year. [0:21:33] It looks like there are more people that were held accountable from what I'm looking at. And September is more or less a match of 2025 based on data. And just kind of looking at the just below the data just below that, it's saying that CDY arrests with at least one drug-related charge. I'm looking at like there's the last one saying 10. Does that mean one out of 10? Pardon for my ignorance on this one. No, so that that means that there was 10 arrests drug related. So oftentimes there may be another charge mixed in with that arrest. I see. I laid out in that regard and then in terms of accountability on the arrest chart, like, that's been that's just the raw number of arrests. The police departments made the red on the red graph there accountability comes ultimately with what the criminal legal system does or does not do with an individual. So I like to remind members of the public that the police department is literally a referral agency. [0:22:32] Our charge is public safety. We respond to incidents, make sure that life safety matters are addressed first. We then preserve evidence, interview witnesses, conduct investigations, and make appropriate referrals, whether that's a crime that's referred to the criminal justice system for prosecution or a mental health incident that's referred to a service provider or to the emergency room for that level of care. that's what we do. We are a referral agency. Thank you. Commissioner Ball. Thank you. Thanks for being here chief. So I have a question. The first question is, well actually I have two. I think I only have two. Can you explain, because a number of people have asked me, what is the definition of suspicious event? It's probably one of the murkiest incident categories [0:23:28] that we have. And it's everything from, I think maybe I saw a drug deal to I heard a bump in the night, I saw this person on the street. And you know, it's an area where our officers need both our officers and our emergency communications specialists are very attuned to not adopt anyone bias when they're reporting something, and then going and figuring out what it is. And of course, you know, we're happy when we can go solve a bump in the night that someone heard in their house or their car hasn't been broken into. And And then other times it's just nondescript conduct that makes really people feel, they don't feel safe, right? So they're calling the police. And it's, again, it's a messy bucket of data and it accounts for quite a bit of our work. Yeah, that's for sure. I just, I know a few people have said to me when I've given them some statistics and they, and I've said, well, the second most common is suspicious event. [0:24:25] and they've said, well, what does that mean? And I'm not sure that I've been able to give them a really good description, but it sounds to me like it's sort of a bit of a catch-all for what you can't quite label, but as you say, when someone feels somehow unsafe. So my question is, my other question is about, and I'm not sure what to make of this. So when we first, several months ago, the top 72 wasn't 72. The top 72 a few months ago was like top 56. And then it was top 64, and now it's top 72. So I'm not sure what to make of that. What is the fact that the number of people is increasing for just the same 20%? What does that, in your professional opinion, [0:25:23] what does that tell you, if anything? Yeah, it is, it's a little difficult to understand and what it tells me is that we have more people engaged in conduct where they're having police contact. And when you drill down on this a little bit more, I mean, obviously we know all the names for these bars that are on the chart and a lot of these folks are the people that we see in the downtown district that are on house. So they're sleeping in vestibules. So they're being, you know, people are calling in, reporting trespasses, they're seeing with alcohol containers, they're seeing potentially using drugs, they're seeing having mental health crises, those kinds of incidents that are triggering a response to them, to these people. And then really, what I think it's showing is that despite our best efforts, that we're not meeting the needs of this group, right? And whether that need is greater accountability to make them make different decisions? Is it, do we not have enough shelter options [0:26:23] for people to get off the street? Which I would argue that that is true. It is all of these different influences that we're seeing play out in the downtown and manifesting in the behavior of these individuals that again, when you think about it, relatively small slice of the population, but driving quite a bit of work not only for the police department, but also for fire, particularly on the ambulance side, EMS needs. Yeah, I mean, the number changes a little bit, but the actual numbers behind the number of people hasn't really changed over the last couple of months. Like for example, the number that are homeless versus not homeless, that percentage is basically unchanged. And the only thing that I noticed this month is I think that the trespass of the top 72 [0:27:14] is now much higher than the number of, quote, suspicious event, which would seem to indicate if it's trespass that they, because they don't have a place to go either during the day or at night, that they are trespassing. Is that reasonably accurate? That's a very accurate assessment. And you know, when you think about the response to the College Street block adjacent to City Hall Park, DPW has done a really great job of cleaning that block every two weeks. We've got the camera deployed out there now. So we've moved the behavior that was essentially people living on that north side of the block. And they have gone, you know, around the corner up on St. Paul Street on the private property where they're trespassing as you noticed or down to the ATM vestibule at college in [0:28:12] Pine Street and trespass there. And that is a direct result of they don't have anywhere else to go. So a lot of these people are quite service resistant too. So they might not all go to a shelter option. They are constantly engaged with either our CSL street outreach or police officers and services are attempted to be coordinated, but it's not always well I guess it, you know, once again makes the complete argument for why a hundred shelter, you know, being able to shelter an additional 100 people is not an, is a number that's within, a number that is accurate. A hundred. Or is, I mean, obviously it would be better if it was more, but is a hundred a, I mean talking about 72. Now that number keeps going up. It hasn't, I haven't seen it go [0:29:05] down, so I'm not sure what that says, but it's not 100, it's 72. So that means that you know, and you only go down to a certain level. So I'm sure there, I assume that there's another grouping, if you look at that blue, the one where it says incident counts for the top 72 people on page, what page is that, on page 10 that there's also another grouping of people if you went beyond 17 incidents. Is there a large group of people also in the 10 to 17 range? Jeff can speak to that a little more clearly than I can, but yes, I understand that that it's not a dramatic drop off. The charges kind of keep us off. And you know, so we've got, say, 72 unique individuals there. Really, we haven't had a lot of insert response to the flying A, which is... is the area down in the waterfront near the urban reserve. [0:30:03] There's quite a few folks in camp down there. And when you think about even what the mayor talks about, there's about 300 unhoused people living in the community. So is 100 bed shelter the right number? Is it not? I don't know, I'm not a housing expert, but I do feel as though that some of this conversation is really allowing great to be the enemy of good. We need some level of low barrier shelter to get people off the street, especially as we're bearing down on November. I think that to your point, our trespass incidents illustrates exactly why that's a need in addition to what we know a Vermont winner can bring. Yeah, great. Thank you, thanks so much for your time. Thank you. Any other questions or comments from commissioners? Okay, hearing none, we will go back. Thank you, Chief. [0:30:58] We will go back in our agenda to adopt our last month's meeting. Last meetings minutes is the phrase I'm looking for. We also have been joined by Commissioner Depper, so we have a quorum. Is there a motion to adopt the previous meetings minutes? We've also been joined by Commissioner Comerford. Susie? Hello colleagues, long time no see. Hello. Hello, I want to say to the chief, a huge thank you. I remember when you came to our first meeting and you look like you've worked hard, not only with your brain but with your heart and our city and I want to really thank you for that. That's a gift that has really been given on a regular basis. So I'm wondering about the morale of the staff. This has been going on for a long time now. I've been on the commission for many, many years. [0:31:56] It's just gotten more and more challenging with fewer and fewer officers and those who have been here the whole time, you know, it must be incredibly exhausted. And those who are new are also probably feeling it. So I have two questions, you know, sort of one is what's the morale of our staff, of our sworn officers? And the second thing is in the midst of all of these statistics, what are three things you think that are immediately necessary to go forward that are doable? First of all, thank you so much for those kind words, Commissioner Comerford. I do appreciate that. It's been an honor to come back here. I think most people know that this is my last policing position before I figure out what I can do with the remainder of my adult life. And it's been nothing but an honor to come back and serve the city of Burlington. [0:32:51] I would say that the morale of the police department is low. They're tired. We've worked at a pace which I've described as unsustainable. And we're at a place now where our uniform patrol division simply does not have enough officers to offer a ton of relief. And I hope that we can figure out a recruitment strategy that will bring people here to do this work. Because like we like to remind ourselves here doing the work is that there's reasons why we're here. And there's reason why we wanna serve this community, this police department with this peer group. And I really applaud the work that this team does from incident response to criminal investigation. It's really remarkable in my mind because the organization is still performing like it did when I was here, when we had 90 plus officers in all the spots filled. [0:33:48] But again, I worry about the longevity of those efforts. So, in terms of what I feel would be extraordinarily impactful work to get done, one, from an operational standpoint, and really a community care taking standpoint, I'd really love to see this low barrier shelter figured out. I'm ambivalent on the size of it, but we need another resource. 2, I would like to see greater recognition that the city of Burlington is an endpoint in a lot of ways that feeds into what we have in terms of the behavior that's playing out in our streets. When you look at the number of people that are transported via ambulance or other police departments to the medical center, they're treated in the emergency room and then released out into the community. [0:34:35] People that are released from the courthouse that are on housed here on Cherry Street or from probation and parole or any number of the other service related service providers here in town. We do absorb what I would call an outsized number of folks that are entrenched. Sometimes with substance use disorder or mental health crisis, involved with the criminal legal system are very, You know, are very kind of complicated individuals that aren't always willing to engage productively or constructively with our service providers. And I think that the city needs some assistance in that regard. And I believe that the mayor is on a path to find partners, state, state partners in order to help the city kind of navigate that. [0:35:20] I mentioned the recruitment challenge and then in terms of the criminal legal system, I definitely feel as though that the support court helped address the backlog and that there is a greater throughput in terms of the number of cases that are being clear. defendants are being seen more efficiently. However, what we really struggle with is the construct of our bail law and the frustration that we hear constantly from the business community about why can this person steal from my store time and time again and be released out on the street by the court. That's because of the construct of the statute. And until the General Assembly kind of takes that up and examines that and looks at different ways in which folks that can be held accountable while they're on, particularly pre-trial conditions of release, which ultimately if they're going out and violating those that's contempt for the bench, there should be a limit to, [0:36:18] as to the number of times a person can do that before ultimately that person is incarcerated pre-trial so they can no longer harm the community. So those are kind of three buckets of work that I like to think about. Thanks, Chief. Commissioner, did you have anything else? No. Thank you. Okay. We will go back to adopting the minutes from our previous meeting. Is there a motion to adopt the previous meeting's minutes? Is there a second? Second. All those in favor say aye. Any opposed? Okay. The motion carries. We will, excuse me, we will now move onto commission business. First item is reports from committees. Our complaints committee will meet immediately after the closing of this meeting and then we have no updates from the animal control committee. [0:37:17] So very brief updates from committees. Now I would like to move on to the discussion of our annual report. Shibe has posted a new draft of a report that I put together leaning heavily on the previous version of the report, just with an eye on clarity and brevity and keeping a lot of the data in an appendix. It is posted to Civic Clerk. I can also email it for folks if they don't have it immediately available. Since this was posted so recently, I thought I might give folks a minute to read over it. The report itself is only a couple of pages long, so I think that should be doable. Does anyone have any immediate thoughts or would people like a minute to read it? Chair, I just did just have a couple of thoughts on the condensed draft and appendix. We did generate, I didn't see it on here, we did generate an artifact from our discussion [0:38:15] with regards to the commission's roles and responsibilities that wasn't reflected on here, and we did do some work with regard to the website to clean it up. When you say an artifact, what do you mean? I mean the, what did we call it at the time? A fossil. Yeah, the resolution that we generated. Yes. Okay. I will make a note to add the resolution. I'll make a mention of it. Well, what would you like me to do? Would you like to add the appendix or would you like to make a mention of it in the text? Yeah. If we could just make a mention of it in the text as well as the commission's work to get the website more usable for the public. Dates to website. Does anyone have thoughts on those two items? I would just add that I think the I actually thought that there had been something in here and maybe I maybe it was a prior [0:39:15] A prior Through version yeah, I thought there was two I might I could I maybe I'm sure that it was in there It's possible that I and I don't know where So it's under number E in the other in the prior version. So it's on page 11 of 11. Well, that's fine. I was talking about the condensed draft and the defendant. No, no, no, I understand. I'm just saying we were I was just saying I know that it was there somewhere and it was in the prior draft. So it probably is not probably would not be that difficult to just take from one and put into another. No, I'm happy to do that. Yeah. put into another. No, I'm happy to do that. Yeah. He said it was E? Yeah. Okay. I mean, I think that, I think that condense, the condensed is a, barring the two items that [0:40:13] Robert just brought up, is a good synopsis just to keep in mind that on page, what page would be before appendix A so under acknowledgments or before acknowledgments that we just need to have a place for all commissioners to sign so that they have read acknowledging that they've read the report. And the only question that I have is the appendices which are pretty lengthy. I'm wondering, and I don't know if the chief is still on, but has, you know, have these statistics and graphs, et cetera, have they been reviewed by the, trying to think what [0:41:06] his title is, Jeff, the data analyst, so that we know that, you know, where that information is coming from? I don't see, I mean, there's a lot of data on here, but I don't know where, I'm not really sure I know where all of that, all the information has come from. So just wanted to make sure, and I don't know if the, I think it's possible the chief has left. So- Chief, are you still with us? Still here, actually. Thank you. Oh, okay. Oh, wonderful, you're still there. So, Chief, on all the, there's a number of appendices appendix A1 through A10, and there's a number of graphs, you know, data, complaint counting, data interpretation, and I'm just wondering, is this information that, you know, that Jeff [0:42:04] has taken a look at and has, you know, has offered an opinion on, and at least in terms of, you know, what he feels, you know, is that they're accurate. I appreciate the question. Jeff was the source for a lot of the data. In terms of his interpretation of this analysis, I know that he has some different thoughts around that and he gave it a cursory look before the last commission meeting when we first had visibility on this particular report. And we actually have shared some information with the chair about the denominator and how other criminal justice institutions are using different denominators to assess these percent files. So I don't want to speak for Jeff, but I know that he would enjoy an opportunity to [0:42:58] kind of look at this data, and in particular the analyses and to offer some other interpretations. Okay, and at the beginning of that I may have missed that you're saying that the data did come He was asked for data This is not necessarily his interpretation of the data, but he was asked for the data. So we know where the data came from, right? Yes, my understanding came in large part from our public data portal and then anything that wasn't immediately available that he was Delivering some other data sets to then Commissioner Genoria. Okay All right, so I don't know if this is the right moment. I can certainly wait until later so that others have had a chance to chime in. I would certainly want to make that ask to know that Jeff's position and his interpretation was also honored. [0:43:56] I see we have a member of the public. Julia? Hi. Hello. Thank you. I just wanted to say that that data was all received from Jeff and it saved on our SharePoint and all of the data from the publicly available portal. I downloaded it to my private computer because it was a little too big. You don't need to download it to do that filtering and get those denominators, but I found that easier to do so in Excel. And if it would be easier for you to review those statistics, I'm happy to send those over. Apologies, nobody asked for that before today. And I reviewed those with previous police commissioners, Stephanie Caglino, who had done the statistical work in the past. So those charts came with her input. But I just wanted to say that I still exist. [0:44:53] And if you want me to send them to you, I'm happy to do so. Thank you. That's helpful context. Okay, Karen. else. Commissioner von Herman or Depper. No. Okay, great. So we will reach out to Jeff and I will add a note on the resolution the appendix and I will add a note on updates to the website and then I will add room for signatures at the bottom for all commissioners to sign. I think those are the edits that that we have discussed. Is there anything I'm missing? Okay, great. Thank you, Chair. Thank you. Thank you. We will now move on to what will we move on to? [0:45:46] Commendations, I believe, if I can find them. Looks like we have a couple. Good afternoon, BPD colleagues. Last weekend was a challenging weekend to the Queen City. It required a lot of our BPD officers, command staff, emergency communication specialists, and the CAIP team from Friday night all the way into this week. The three incidents each involved challenging dynamics and a lot of expertise, critical judgment calls and coordination across divisions. Thank you to those of you directly involved in these incidents and the ongoing detective work still underway. One of the three incidents was particularly traumatic for the family, our community and the BPD staff who responded, I want you each to know I understand your work is incredibly difficult. Calls like this one stop is all in our tracks. It is hard to process how, excuse me, it is hard to process how violence to this extreme can happen in our city and within a family. These calls also have a real impact on all of us, [0:46:45] but especially on first responders. I hope you were able to each take the time you need to take care of yourselves and find the support you need to process this traumatic call. Thank you for supporting the victim's family, the additional children at the scene, and their families, and those impacted in the wider community. Much of this victim work is unseen by the community because it does not make it into the headline slash news cycle. However, this is a critical part of our response, and I appreciate your care and attention to it. Thank you again for your continued service to Burlington. Peace, Mayor Emma Mulaney Stanak. Number two, to Chief and Sergeant Staughton, who would like to thank you and your agency for allowing TA Sergeant Staughton to come to the academy and support the 122nd basic training class at the Vermont Police Academy during week nine. Having TAs who are willing to spend a week at the academy helping to mold the next generation of law enforcement officers through role modeling, mentoring, and motivation is pivotal to our training program. Your support of this process is greatly appreciated. [0:47:45] Attached is feedback that is gathered from the recruits at the end of the TA week. Questions are on the scale of one to five, five being the highest rating. There's also an option for recruits to write in any other comments. This is a great feedback tool for the TA so they can see the positive impact they are making on the recruits when they are here. We want to acknowledge that having your staff here for a week can be a strain to your departments and we want you all to know that TAs are a vital piece of the successful training program at the BPA. Sharon Roy, CPS, Director of Training, Vermont Criminal Justice Council. And we have one more. All, I wanted to send this email to recognize each of you. We often don't stop and appreciate what a great team we have and verbalize it, whether in an email or in person. This homicide was so brutal and heart-wrenching for multiple reasons, and I was impressed with not only everyone's professionalism, but the respect that everyone showed throughout the investigation to redact it and the rest of the family. This is a difficult case, but I wanted to make sure you all knew how much I appreciated all of your work and how proud and honored I am to work with you, [0:48:44] sincerely, Detective Schaller. And then that has continued. Thank you for sharing this. Detective Schaller is spot on with this from patrol who responded to this brutal scene to detectives that interacted with the children slash family and last but not least to Detective Schaller who had to repeatedly subject herself to what is without a doubt the most horrific audio that I've heard in my career. Thanks to Deputy Chief Winish. And that brings us to the announcement of our next meeting date, which is the, I believe it's the 25th, and I am open to, I'm checking the 24th, which is the Tuesday before Thanksgiving. Does anyone have objections to that? Would we like to move forward a week or back a few days or not? I think last year we might have moved in one direction or another. [0:49:43] Yeah, I haven't gone to look and see where the, when the meeting in December falls. That also is a couple of days before the 20, we ran into this last year, I remember. One, two, three. Yeah, it's the 22nd. So I think that one I would like to move either, my preference would be to move it a week earlier in December. If folks can make that work. the last Tuesday the fourth Tuesday or Tuesday okay and there so there are five Tuesdays in December yeah yeah 22nd the only question I would have is if we move it we maybe it would be better to move both of them you know one up a week and whether or not for the chief whether or not that would skew you know because obviously the Chiefs report is done for both the Commission and the Public safety committee if that is problematic to move that to move them to the meeting [0:50:40] date. No challenges here whatsoever. We'll make it work. Okay great. Thank you. Any commissioners have any objections to either of those? Okay great. Do we do we need to vote on that? Do we need to vote on that? I think if we all just agree. Okay. We'll just change that. Yes. Noted for Shribe. Okay. That brings to the end of our meeting and like I said we will have a complaints committee meeting immediately following the closing of this meeting. Is there a motion to adjourn? So moved. Is there a second? All those in favor say aye. Aye. Any opposed? Okay we are adjourned.